DIFFERENCE IN GLICATED HEMOGLOBIN LEVEL BETWEEN BORONATE AFFINITY METHOD AND ION EXCHANGE-HIGH PERFORMANCE LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY METHOD IN TYPE 2 DIABETES MELLITUS

Tuti Asryani, Ellyza Nasrul, Rikarni Rikarni, Tutty Prihandani

Abstract


Background: Glycated Hb (HbA1c) test is needed to control glycemic in high prevalence type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM) patients. Hemoglobin fraction separated and chemical reaction are two main concepts in HbA1c test. Ion exchange-high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and boronate affinity use first concept. Ion exchange-HPLC is reference method in most of clinical laboratorium. Point of care testing (POCT) with boronate affinity method that has been standardized by international institution is available. The aim of this study was to compare boronate affinity POCT method and ion exchange-HPLC method.

Method: This cross sectional study was conducted to 22 type 2 DM patients those fullfill inclusion and exclusion criteria in January 2017 to February 2018. Level of HbA1c was assayed with boronate affinity POCT and ion exchange-HPLC method. T-test was used to analyse data and no significance difference if p>0.005

Results: Subjects of this study are women (59.1%) more than men (40.9%) with age mean 59.23 years old (8.1). Uncontroled type 2 DM (77.3%) more than controled type 2 DM (22.7%).Mean of HbA1 level was 8.0% (1.7) in boronate affinity POCT and 8.3% (1.8) in ion exchange-HPLC. T-test showed no significance difference between those two HbA1C assay methods (p>0.005).

Conclusion: There was no difference HbA1c level between boronate affinity POCT method and ion exchange-HPLC method.


Keywords


boronate affinity, type 2 diabetes mellitus, HbA1c, ion exchange-HPLC

Full Text:

PDF

References


Perkeni, 2015. Konsensus Pengelolaan dan Pencegahan Diabetes Melitus Tipe 2 di Indonesia 2015. PB Perkeni. Hal: 1-79.

ADA, 2017. Glycemic Targets. In: Diabetes Care. P: 48-56.

Kilpatrick Eric S, 2000. Glycated Haemoglobin In The Year 2000. In: J Clin Pathol. P: 335-39.

Syed Iftikhar A A, 2011. Glycated Haemoglobin; Past, Present and Future Are We Ready For The Change. In: Review Article, J Pak Med Assoc, Ireland. P: 383-87.

NGSP, 2016. International Federation of Clinical Chemistry (IFCC) Standardization of HbA1c. P: 1-4.

Gupta S, Jain U, Chauhan N, 2017. Laboratory Diagnosis of HbA1c: A Review. In: Journal of Nanomedicine Research. P: 1-10.

Little Randie R and Robets William L, 2009. A review of Variant Hemoglobin Interfering With Hemoglobin A1c Measurement. In: Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology. Vol.3. P: 446-51.

Karami A and Baradaran, 2014. Comparative Evaluation Of Three Different Methods For HbA1c Measurement With High-Performance Chromatography In Diabetic Patient. In: Advanced Biomed Research. P: 1-11.

National Institute for Health Research (NHS), 2016. Point of Care HbA1c Tests- Diagnosis Of Diabetes. Diunduh dari www.oxford.dec.nihr.ac.uk. dilihat pada tanggal 21 Januari 2017.

Genc S, Gurdol F, Kanzamar-Ozer M, Ince N, Ozcelik F et al., 2014. The Analytical Performance of Four Different Glycated Hemoglobin Methods. In: Medical Chemistry. P: 501-05.

Rhea JM and Molinaro R, 2014. Pathology Consultation On HbA1c Methods and Interferences. In: AJCP. P: 5-16.

Razi F, Esfahani E, Farzani M, Tootee A, Qorbani M, et al., 2015. Effect of The Different Assay of HbA1c on Diabetic Patients Monitoring. In: Journal of Diabetes and Metabolic Disorders. P: 1-4.

Paputungan Sri R dan Sanusi H, 2014. Peranan Pemeriksaan Hemoglobin A1c pada Pengelolaan Diabetes Melitus. Dalam: Cermin Dunia Kedokteran. Vol 41. No 9. Hal: 650–55.

Bode Bruce W, Irvin BJ, Pierce JA, Allen MA, Clark AL, 2007. Advances In Hemoglobin A1c Point of Care Technology. In: Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology. Vol.1. P: 405-11.

Schwartz KL, Monsur J, Hammad A, Bartoces MG, Neale AV, 2009. Comparison of Point Of Care and Laboratory HbA1c Analysis: A Metronet Study. In: J Am Board Fam Med. Vol 22. P: 461-63.

Grant DA, Dunseath GJ, Churm, Luzio, 2017. Comparison Of A Point-Of-Care Analyzer For The Determination Of HbA1c With HPLC Method. In: Practical Laboratory Medicine. P: 26-9.

Alcala Garcia H, Arguelles Ruiz A, Carvallo Cedillo B, 2009. Effect of The Method To Measure Levels of Glycated Hemoglobin On Individual Clinical Decisions, Comparison of An Immunoassay With High-Performance Liquid Chromatography. In: American Journal Clinical Pathology. P: 332-5.

Muller A and Jones G, 2013. Evaluation of Four POCT-Systems for The Measurement of HbA1c. In: EKF Diagnostic. P: 1-5.

Ullman M David and Burtis Carl A, 2006. Chromatography. In: Tietz textbook of Clinical Chemistry and Molecular Diagnostics. 4th Edition. P: 142-161.

Sacks David B and Path C, 2006. Diabetes Mellitus. In: Tietz Textbook of Clinical Chemistry and Molecular Diagnostics. Ed 4th. Elsevier Inc. P: 853-63.

Keohane M Elaine, 2016. Hemoglobin Metabolism. In: Rodak’s Hematology Clinical Principle and Application. Ed 5th . P: 124-35.




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.24293/ijcpml.v25i2.1466

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.